A new study by Good Jobs First, "Ending Job Piracy, Building Regional Prosperity," reports on a couple of success stories. Notably, these have not involved state governments, but take place in two metropolitan areas, in Dayton, Ohio, and in Denver. The study also reports on failed regional efforts in Minneapolis/St. Paul and Kansas City (but see more below).
The oldest of these successes is the Metro Denver Economic Development Corporation, created in the late 1980s. Its aim is to promote the entire metropolitan area as a single region, using transparency and information exchange among municipalities to prevent site selection consultants from playing different cities off against one another. All members sign a Code of Ethics committing themselves to these goals.
The Code is not a law, but it does provide for a dispute resolution process in the case of an alleged violation. A complaint triggers this process:
the Chair of the organization will call together three to five members into a meeting with the offender. If the member’s behavior is determined to be inappropriate, the offending individual is asked to issue a public apology or issue a statement to staff correcting their action and guiding future actions.As the Good Jobs First report points out, dispute resolution has only been invoked three times in the 26 years the agreement has been in effect, and no Economic Development Corporation member has had to be expelled, the strongest sanction available for violating the Code of Ethics.
In Dayton/Montgomery County, Ohio, there are two programs that promote regional cooperation. Economic Development/Government Equity (ED/GE) began in 1991, and provides a $5 million annual pool for "regionally significant projects in the county." It also shares increased tax revenues with slower-growing municipalities in the county. Applications for the $5 million fund are judged competitively and the process will only consider funding for relocations under very narrow circumstances and only then with a letter of support from the city losing the company.
In addition, all the Montgomery county municipalities, as well as some in neighboring counties, participate in a program called Business First! that promotes the region as a whole and, like Denver's Code of Ethics, requires information sharing when a company is seeking to move within the region. Business First! also provides for a transitional tax-sharing agreement when there is an intra-regional move.
The new report emphasizes the need for engagement with economic development officials, because they actually do the work and they represent the institutional memory necessary for these agreements to remain viable in the long term. As always, transparency is a key element that is a precondition for accountable governance.
In addition to these success stories, potential good news on the job piracy front came out of Missouri last week. On July 1, Democratic Governor Jay Nixon signed a bill passed by the Republican-majority legislature that would disallow the use of state incentives to firms relocating from four Kansas counties to the four counties that make up the core of Kansas City, Missouri. This represents a dramatic turnaround from 18 months ago, when both Nixon and Kansas Republican Governor Sam Brownback told New York Times reporter Louise Story, on camera, that they would continue poaching from the other state.
Missouri's law takes effect only if Kansas passes a parallel law. As Kansas City business leaders have pointed out, the two states have given more than $200 million in tax breaks for relocations, only to see a net 400 jobs move to Kansas. Unfortunately, so far Kansas leaders have given no indication that they will follow suit. However, the Missouri law gives Kansas until August 28, 2016 to do so. Hopefully, some sense will prevail in Kansas by then.
Cross-posted at Angry Bear.